Too-Tall's gang is trying to build a fort in the tree where an endangered bird is, and Brother and Sister want to find a way to save the yellow popinjay. Mama and Papa suggest finding a way to reach a compromise.

Smarty and Elmo want to learn something new together. Elmo wants to learn more about kindness. Smarty shows Elmo different ways people can show kindness to one another.

Dwight is upset because Angela agrees to date Andy. Jim meets Dwight in the stairwell and explains why he left Scranton, showing Dwight empathy.

After bouncing a little too much, Tigger sends a rock over a ledge that destroys Eeyore's house. While trying to remove the large rock using Rabbit's plan, Tigger again causes trouble with his bouncing. Tigger creates a plan of his own to make sure Eeyore has a house for the winter.

Elmo and cookie monster both love cookies. Elmo is the only one with cookies. Due to an unfortunate situation Elmo's cookies get stolen and now he does not have enough cookies to share. Cookie Monster still wants cookies but Elmo does not have enough to share. Elmo decides to split his cookie and share with Cookie Monster.