After bouncing a little too much, Tigger sends a rock over a ledge that destroys Eeyore's house. While trying to remove the large rock using Rabbit's plan, Tigger again causes trouble with his bouncing. Tigger creates a plan of his own to make sure Eeyore has a house for the winter.

Dwight is upset because Angela agrees to date Andy. Jim meets Dwight in the stairwell and explains why he left Scranton, showing Dwight empathy.

Lernert had recently encountered Rola, a voyager who had just eaten a forbidden fruit that made her sick. He taught Rola about edible and inedible fruits and how to spot them. Lernert also attempted to be friendly and initiate a conversation with Rola who willingly decided to leave and ignore Lernert.

Ben, a rich man who ones a department store, wants to build land on Lester and his family's home, so he puts up a foreclosure agreement. Andy brings people together to help Lester pay for the money that Ben is asking for. When Ben won't budge, Andy takes matters into his own hands and shows Ben how mean he really is being to Lester and his family.

Bluey and Bingo learn how to compromise and share, in order for both of them to be happy.