Elmo and cookie monster both love cookies. Elmo is the only one with cookies. Due to an unfortunate situation Elmo's cookies get stolen and now he does not have enough cookies to share. Cookie Monster still wants cookies but Elmo does not have enough to share. Elmo decides to split his cookie and share with Cookie Monster.

Robin Williams is explaining the concept of the word, "conflict," to the two headed monster. This is a new concept to them, so he breaks it down into simpler terms. Robin and the monster begin to argue and realize that they are in the middle of a conflict.

After Agnes's toy unicorn is accidentally disintegrated, she runs a tough bargain with Gru to get another one.

In this episode Elmo learned how to problem solve with a group of friends. While playing a game they realize there might not be enough toys for everyone in the group and all the spots in the game are filled. Elmo and his friends come up with a resolution so everyone can play together.

Daniel Tiger doesn't want to share his stickers with his little sister, Margaret. Daniel's father explains that giving Margaret a sticker could be fun for the both of them. Daniel decides to share some stickers with Margaret, and he realizes it was more fun than if he had played with them alone.