Eleanor wakes up to find that the Good Place is in chaos: there are flying shrimp, a giant roaming giraffe, music playing, and everyone is running around dressed in blue and yellow. All these occurences are results of Eleanor's unethical decisions from the night before.
Eddy commits an unselfish deed by replacing a dead bulb on a Christmas tree, prompting Santa to deliver presents to all of the kids in the cul-de-sac. It is clear that one selfless act isn't enough to change his character, however, as he takes everyone's presents for himself.