Mandy's shadow, who is sweet and pleasant, has a mental breakdown after being forced to confront the innocent delusions she has about her stuffed unicorns. After facing the harsh reality, she undergoes a mental upheaval and becomes cyincal like Mandy. Mandy and her shadow then destroy all of shadow Mandy's stuffed unicorns.
North Shore High School competes with Marymount Prep in the Mathletes State Championship. During the sudden death round, Cady is put up against Miss Caroline Krafft, who does not have a good sense of fashion. Cady realizes that making fun of Miss Krafft will not give her a better chance at winning or make her a better person; rather, she should focus on herself and rely on her own skills to win.