Billy, in his time of need, takes a trip into his imagination where he meets his inner self. He shares his dilemma about his fear of clowns, and his inner self tells him that clowns aren't scary, they're just different. However, instead of teaching tolerance, his inner self teaches hatred, and this causes Billy to grab Grim's scythe and rage at Mandy and Grim in their clown costume.
Billy thinks Grim killed everyone he cares about. Grim denies his accusation until Mandy comes along with a box and ominously invites them over for dinner. Billy thinks Mandy ate the people he cares about, but then Grim suggests he's jumping to conclusions. The two try to find evidence that she is a cannibal. Billy continues to be paranoid, sticking to his belief that Mandy ate the people he cared about, but Grim keeps a level head until finally joining him in his paranoia, only for it to be revealed that everything was a plan for Billy's surprise birthday party.
Billy's Little League team loses 99 - 0 against Mindy's team. Although Mandy is an exceptional baseball player, Billy continues to insist that girls are not allowed to play. Grim comes up with a plan to get Mandy on the team: he simply puts Mandy in a baseball uniform and introduces her as "Manfred." Billy falls for it.
A Chupacabra comes out of Billy's television as he was watching a video tape Grim rented from a video store in the underworld. Billy, typical of his character, names the dangerous creature "Daisy." Grim warns Billy that Chupacabras are bloodsuckers that only bring suffering. Billy ignores the warning.